Sunday, August 14, 2005

Support the troops, but just the live ones

This is why you always have to read the comments. Floyd Alvis Cooper, come on down for your 15 minutes of fame!

  1. Floyd Alvis Cooper Says:

    I know this isn’t going to popular on this website, but may I just point something out?

    A soldier’s #1 job is to stay alive. If you die, you can’t accomplish the mission, and you weaken your team and put your buddies in danger.

    Obviously Sheehan’s son, I forget his name at the moment, didn’t die on purpose, and he may well have have had no control over the circumstances that let to his death.

    BUT.

    In war, there are no excuses. You find a way to stay alive, whatever it takes — if you’re a good soldier. Sheehan’s son didn’t do that. He paid the price. but he als failed the mission and let down his buddies.

    As a soldier, he was a failure. He was brave (maybe), but he was also incompetent.

    So, really, how much exactly are we supposed to grieve over this guy? Isn’t a certain amount of disapproval in order for the guy — and by extension his mom, for making such a fuss over a person who was, in the last analysis, by definition a loser?

    So shouldn’t Mrs. Sheenhan be showing a little more shame about the situation and maybe not wanting to get her son and his shortcoming splashed all over the media?

    Something to consider, anyway.

No comments: